Dial-up. ISDN.
Cable. DSL.
With all these choices, which one
makes the most sense? A lot of factors
contribute to the answer,
and this chart can help.
|
Connection Type |
Analog |
ISDN |
Cable |
DSL |
Wireless |
T1 |
|
Service
Providers |
All major ISPs and
Telephone Companies
|
All major ISPs and Telephone
Companies |
Time Warner, AtHome are the major
players |
Telephone Companies and Select
ISPs |
DirecPC and StarBand are the main
players |
Telephone Companies |
|
Benefits |
Most widely used connection, available everywhere
Lowest cost service
Analog modem is least expensive connection peripheral
|
Twice as fast as analog
Dials and connects in 3-6 seconds
Very few busy signals and disconnects
|
Fastest connection speed of all the choices
24/7 Connection
Easy to configure
|
High speed connection over existing phone lines
Reasonably priced
24/7 Always-on connection
|
Four times the speed of ISDN
High speed access, even in rural areas
|
Exremely fast, reliable connection
Monster bandwidth for audio/video applications
Inherent ability to connect multiple machines
|
|
Drawbacks |
Slowest connection speed
Susceptible to busy signals and disconnects
Customer would expect more when paying for usage
|
Costs more than analog
Not as widely available
|
Expensive installation for business
Mainly offered in residential areas
|
Limited coverage area in the US
30-60 day waiting period in most cities
|
Requires a satellite dish and
a modem
Expensive solution
Downloads are via satellite but uploads through regular
ISP
|
Very expensive
Limited availability
|
|
Price
Range |
$20-$40 per
month for phone line, $15-$25 for Internet Service
Some companies
impose a 1.5 cent/minute meter charge on the line
|
$40 - $60 per month for line, $20-$35 per month for Internet Service.
Some companies impose a 1.5 cent/minute meter
charge on the line |
$50-$400 Installation Cost,
$35 - $80 Monthly Service
Fee |
$100 - $300 Installation (Often Includes
Cost of Modem)
$50 - $150 per month, depending on desired
speed (640K up to 1.6MBs) |
$200 for dish & modem,
$100 - $150/month for up to 200
hrs/month |
Up to
$5000 Setup Fee
$600 - $1000 monthly service
fee |
|
Availability |
Everywhere |
Major cities and many suburbs, rare find in
rural areas |
Still spotty, but growing rapidly. |
Major Metropolitan areas |
Anywhere there is an unobstructed line of
sight to the south |
Mainly in larger
cities |
|
Summary |
Best connection for
remote locations where no other service is available
|
A better choice than analog, not as fast as
DSL or Cable |
Fastest, most reliable connection to date –
but mainly residential. If
available in your business district – grab it! |
Ideal choice for Public Internet Access as it
offers many benefits at a reasonable price. Geared more toward businesses than
the Cable Modem. Still wet behind the ears, but growing rapidly. |
This is the choice for remote areas, but you
will still need to use a normal dial-up ISP to send information to the
net. The dish will only capture the download information. |
Only consider T1 lines when dealing with four
or more terminals in one location. Location must have HUGE potential to justify this
cost. |